Post by John Okiyi Kalu (@JOK)
ADC And The Disputed Signature
-John Okiyi Kalu
Before the Supreme Court referred this matter back to the Federal High Court, I had argued that the central issue before Senator David Mark and the ADC leadership was whether Nafiu Bala Gombe actually signed the purported resignation letter attributed to him.
I also pointed out that although the simplest way to establish the authenticity of a signature is for the signatory to acknowledge it, the law recognises other methods of authentication.
Section 101 of the Evidence Act 2011 (as amended) empowers a court to compare a disputed signature with other signatures proved to have been made by the same person.
In his judgment, Justice Peter O. Lifu applied this principle. At pages 53–56, he relied on established authorities, including Ishaq v. INEC, Momah v. Egwuawa and Adenle v. Olude, to explain the court’s power to independently compare disputed signatures. He also observed that expert evidence is not invariably necessary for such an exercise.
The judge compared the signature on Exhibit ADC 1, the purported resignation letter, with Gombe’s signatures on other documents in the court record, including his witness statements on oath.
Having identified material differences in their structure, style and formation, he concluded at page 56:
“Consequently, the alleged resignation letter, that is, Exhibit ADC 1, is fictitious or fabricated. I so hold.”
At page 63, he further held that the purported resignation letter could not be relied upon as proof that Gombe had voluntarily relinquished his office.
Another important point in the judgment is the distinction between certification and authentication. As Justice Lifu explained at page 53, certifying a document as a true copy does not automatically establish that the person whose signature appears on it actually signed it.
The lesson is simple: the existence or certification of a document does not, by itself, establish the authenticity of a disputed signature. Equally, denying a signature does not automatically establish forgery. The court must examine the available evidence.
What Happens Next?
We must, however, wait to see whether the appellate courts will agree with Justice Lifu’s reasoning and conclusions. Until the appeals are exhausted, INEC should refrain from taking any action that could alter the existing political status quo in the ADC. The prudent course is to allow the judicial process to run its full course.
It is equally important to put the timing of this judgment in perspective. This matter has been in the judicial system long before the current political developments. Suggestions that the judgment was a reaction to ADC’s purported growing popularity are therefore neither here nor there.
Indeed, the timing issue arose because the Supreme Court directed that the matter be tried afresh before Justice Lifu. The Federal High Court was simply carrying out that directive.
We should separate the legal issues from political speculation, allow the appellate courts to have their say, and urge INEC to exercise restraint until the available appeals have been fully determined.
-JOK
11/11/2026

0 likes · 0 comments · 0 shares